Showing posts with label gender roles. Show all posts
Showing posts with label gender roles. Show all posts

Monday, September 28, 2020

Gender Bender

 

I don't remember exactly when converstaions around gender started with Manya - but one instance that does come to mind is when Manya came back home from kindergarten, very knowledgeably stating, "Mom, did you know X's dad identifies as a girl - he is still dad not mom but feels like a woman."

It took me a few minutes to digest what she was saying. Well, I was aware of X's dad but the maturity of the parents to come to school and address the elephant in the room (especially in birthday parties) was so refreshing that I was bowled over. I asked her what had happened and realized that in her own simple way she had understood and accepted what many educated adults refuse to even acknowledge. And that is why they say, start them young. Read another related post here. 

Well all that context was just to say that we time and again have had conversations on gender identities, gender roles, breaking moulds etc etc - basically normalizing the already normal. 

And, Manya has been so mature about everything that it has been really easy... or atleast that was that I had been thinking. However, as she was drafting the birth certificate of her newest toy (a creepy robotic cat - maybe a post about that could be next) last week, I was surprised she said Cat in the Gender column. So I asked her about it.

Me: Manya how come your birth certificate says Gender is Cat. I thought gender is male or female. Cat is just the type of animal.

Manya: No mom. Gender is what you identify as - you can identify as a boy or a girl or what you feel. Beatrice identifies as a cat. So her gender is cat.

Me (thoroughly confused as to where to start - wondering that the discussion of biological sex vs. the social construct of gender would be a little too early to bring on, trying a simpler approach) - Umm okay so Manya I think gender is for human  beings - for animals, the sex is identified as male or female.

Manya: Yeah, so Beatrice's sex is female but her gender is cat.

Me (understanding this is going nowhere): But Beatrice is already an animal - a cat.

Manya: Mom, Beatrice is not a human being and Beatrice is not an animal. Beatrice is a toy - she is a robot - she identifies her gender as cat - what is the problem with that. Anybody can identify as a cat. And that can be their gender. 

Me (parking this conversation for later): Actually, nothing. You are right she is a toy. And I know so many days I actually identify as a cat or a female dog... (that part more to myself...)

Clearly looks like I have my daughter throughly confused (or not...) but after those five minutes, I was not so worried - it doesn' matter what she really understands and how deeply - what matters is that her mind is open to possibilities...and hopefully complete acceptance. I will take that tiny victory to satiate myself for the time being. More conversations will surely follow...

On a lighter note, so what do you identify as today? :)

Friday, April 6, 2018

[Such a long read that it needs a caption. Let’s call it, “The Smoking Lady”.]

So M has still not reached that age or phase where a girl is exposed to a list of what she must or mustn’t, and can or cannot do because of her gender.
Sure, preschool has brought about conversations around pink vs blue, cars vs dolls, and tutus vs trousers but we have been able to navigate thru these by explaining choice and how what is long being followed becomes normal (which means nothing) but its okay to make individual choices. I feel we have been more or less successful even though Manya pushes back - “Mom, i know its my choice and girls needn’t wear only pink but its my life and my body and I choose pink glitter. Thank you very much.”
Cant argue with that either!
Anyways, going back to my initial point of her not having yet faced blatant gender based discrimination, I was shocked to hear from her today, “Mom, just look at that - a lady smoking!”
Thank you Seattle downtown for giving me endless opportunities to educate my kid. ðŸ™„. During our stay here, we have encountered lines of people leaning against building and burning their lives in smoke, drunken brawls that involve choicest of abuses a five year old needn’t have heard, homeless people begging, property destructions in broad daylight, drug addicts approaching high headed in the middle of noon, cars racing and breaking speed limits, and all the PDAs around touristy spots. I am so ready to move to the suburbs.
But for today the smoking lady is of paramount importance. Here’s our conversation...
Me: Manya what is so special about a lady smoking?
M: How can she smoke. Didn’t you say its bad for health and bad for the planet?
Me: Yes it is. But that holds good for both men and women.
M: I know its bad for all but atleast women should not smoke.
Me (absolutely aghast and fumbling to understand the origin of this thought process): I dont understand manya, if its wrong for everyone, nobody should smoke.
M: yes nobody should smoke but atleast women have more sense and they should know better.
Me: why should women know better than men.
M: because girls are the best?
Me: not true, girls and boys can be equally good or equally bad - you have to talk about individuals - you have boy best friends and girl best friends, don’t you?
M: that’s true, you are right.
Me: I am always right.
M: These people need to stop smoking, I feel like puking.
Me: you are right
M: I am always right.
Phew.

Tuesday, August 8, 2017

Normalizing Normal

Read this Huffpost article here. Apparently, a million mom feel Disney should not introduce a two-mom family in Doc-McStuffins.

Hmm. So if heterosexual couples are showcased, it is okay. But homosexuality is apparently a problem for young kids - what a perverted world view we grown ups have!

The younger the child, the easier he/she understands love. And with that simple understanding they can grow up to be inclusive and all embracing members of the society. This kind of resistance is unnatural and not normal - this is not shielding your kids - it is coloring them with the same biases that the parents hold.

Reminds me of this instance when a then 3 year old Manya met a girl with two mommies and asked me, "mommy wow does that girl really have two mommies!" And I told her "yep - you can have one mommy, or one daddy, or both, two mommies, or two daddies or both!" She just smiled. It was so simple. She has since seen two daddies too, and while some adults stood in a corner and stared, the kids, including my daughter didn't even notice. That. Is. Normal.